Handcrafted gourmet bagel balm made from the finest ingredients. No preservatives, no shortcuts.
Buy Now ➜"The spread that turns every bagel into an event."
🛒 Add to Cart — $8.99Roasted garlic, sea salt, olive oil. The one that started it all.
Habanero heat meets smoky paprika. Bold and unapologetic.
Basil, chive, dill & rosemary. Fresh from the garden.
Black truffle, wildflower honey, aged balsamic. Pure luxury.
Loaded with smoked salmon, capers, cream cheese, cherry tomatoes, and a generous swipe of Classic Garlic BagelBalm.
⏲ 10 minutes · Serves 4Artisan crackers, cured meats, aged cheddar, and three BagelBalm varieties for the perfect hosting spread.
⏲ 15 minutes · Serves 8BagelBalm was born in a Brooklyn apartment kitchen in 2019, when founder Maya Lin decided the world needed a better bagel spread. After two years of recipe testing, blind tastings, and way too many bagels, we launched at the Grand Street Farmers Market. Three years and fifty thousand jars later, we're still making every batch by hand in small quantities. No factories. No shortcuts. Just real food, made with real care.
"I've tried every bagel spread out there. BagelBalm is in a league of its own. The Classic Garlic is addictive."
"Bought the sampler pack for a gift. Three days later, my sister ordered her own five-pack. Worth every penny."
"The Truffle Honey is incredible on crostini. Wish they had a bigger jar size for the fancy stuff."